Tag Archives: Charles Herr

Herr-Story by Charles Herr: A look at local days gone by

The Forge House: Owners, Proprietor & Managers, Part VII

The Garmon & CrosbyYears: 1888-1895

In February 1898, Arthur H. and Julia Springsteen moved to West Carthage where Springsteen operated a grocery store and was elected village treasurer, but they soon returned to Orwell in 1903.

Julia Springsteen contracted tuberculosis and died in February 1905.

Arthur soon remarried and this marriage produced a daughter, Julia, in 1907, and a son, Savillian, in 1909.

But his son and second wife both died within a week of each other in February 1912.

Springsteen later married widow Mary Monihen (Moniken?, Monahan?) who had a daughter.

The Springsteens moved to Port Royal, Pennsylvania and Arthur would return periodically to visit remaining family and inlaws.

His Port Royal residence would also be home to aged Orwell relatives. Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr A look at local days gone by

A look at local days gone by 

The Forge House: Owners, Proprietor & Managers, Part VI

The Garmon & Crosby Years: 1888-1895 The Utica Weekly Herald of March 24, 1891 published an announced and then a retracted selection of John Studer as the new Forge House proprietor.

Studer was a hotel proprietor in Watson and had reached a verbal agreement with Dr. Crosby. But Garmon had signed a one-year agreement with partners George B. Kitts of Boonville and Mortimer D. Alger of Rome. Kitts was experienced in running hotels at Boonville and later at Rome where he may have met Mortimer D. Alger.

After the one year Forge House lease, he ran the Lewis Hotel in Fulton and then the Doolittle Hotel in Rome.

While at the Lewis Hotel in 1895, Kitts invested in a company manufacturing fire alarm systems for hotels.

At the time of his death of tuberculosis on April 29, 1913, he had been proprietor of the Orlando Hotel in Corning since 1898.

Mortimer D. Alger ran a popular hardware store in Rome for many years until June 1891. After his stint at the Forge House, Alger concentrated on his camp at Big Island on Fourth Lake.

Originally, camp builders erected a camp for guide Fred Rivett and his brother Peter.

They sold their squatters’ rights to Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr “A Look at Local Days Gone by”

The Forge House: Owners, Proprietor & Managers, Part V

The Garmon & Crosby Years: 1888-1895

In January 1888, Charles Barrett vacated the Forge House and purchased the Moose River Hotel originally owned by Abner Lawrence.

In 1893, Barrett purchased over 125 acres of the former Grant Clearing from Robert Perrie, which included Perrie’s Third Lake House.

Barrett soon erected the famous Bald Mountain House, which would soon rival the Forge House for popularity. Barrett died in March, 1930.

The tract included today’s Bald Mountain Colony.

At the time of Barrett’s leaving in 1888, the Forge House was still a board and batten structure similar to its initial appearance in 1871, though probably made larger over the years. Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr “A Look at Local Days Gone by”

The Forge House: Owners, Proprietor & Managers, Part IV

Alexander Lamberton, a former Presbyterian pastor, had married Eunice B. Hussey in 1864.

Eunice had been a widow who inherited the patent profits due to her deceased husband, Obed Hussey, who invented the mechanical reaper.

Alexander turned to business and the natural sciences and obtained the tract with the hope of establishing a preserve.

Accompanied by Emmett Marks in March 1876, he engineered the first large scale stocking of brook trout, 50,000 small fish, on the Fulton Chain and wrote in FOREST AND STREAM about the experience.

He encouraged Marks’ work with hatching pools under the Desbrough sawmill.

In March 1876, Lamberton renamed the hotel “Forest House” and leased it to Joel T. Comstock who advertised it as “Forest Hotel.” Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr

Arnold’s Manor would begin an architectural decline that terminated with its burning in May 1896.

Cyrus advertised the new hotel as a “first-class country hotel” and that supplies, guides and boats were available.

The hotel’s business started slow and was beginning to pick up when Cyrus drowned at Limekiln Lake in November 1872.

He and his 10-year-old son Will were deer hunting with Daniel Sears, Sam Dunakin and Jack Sheppard. Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr A Look at Local Days Gone by

The Forge House: Owners, Proprietor & Managers, Part II

I now return to J. Milton Buell and Dr. George Desbrough, who on April 1, 1871, bought the 250-acre “Grant Lot” from the executors of Lyman R. Lyon’s Estate.

Before partnering with Desbrough, Buell, born in 1813, and his wife, Lucy Loomis Buell, were farmers in Westmoreland, N.Y. with a daughter, Sarah Adelaide (she preferred “S. Addie”).

They were living in Whitestown at the time of the 1860 census. Buell soon after became proprietor of Utica’s Mansion House which he operated for many years. Continue reading

Share Button

Herr-Story by Charles Herr

The Forge House:Its Owners, Proprietors and Managers

If any image represents early Fulton Chain history, it is the Forge House atop the elevation overlooking the pond as a king viewing his realm.

When the hotel burned in 1924, prominent citizens planned to quickly rebuild it but the era of the big summer hotel had ended, replaced by smaller, shorter stay motoring hotels.

Today, we see a bank, motel, restaurant and a flat grassy knoll instead.

But while the Forge House existed, the traveler was given the name of an individual there who would not fail to provide necessary comforts.

This narrative is about the hotel’s owners, and about the proprietors and managers who usually were not the owners. Continue reading

Share Button